MAX5 AND MAX6 — CONSISTENCY AUDIT
9 November 2026, publication revision r21

RESULT
The audited current paper, supplement, formal-proof correspondence and release
records are internally consistent after the corrections below. No change to a
mathematical theorem, hypothesis, proof body or accepted Lean source was needed.
This is a consistency/preservation audit, not another full Lean proof rebuild
or an independent re-proof of every informal argument.

CORRECTIONS
1. Three stale detailed-section routes in evidence/source-index.json:
   R29_M1: S15.6 -> S15.7;
   R29_M3: S15.7 -> S15.8;
   R29_M2_ONE_IN_OUT: S15.5 -> S15.6.
   The high-attachment route now includes S15.5, the five-center case.
   JSON, text and TeX source indexes are synchronized. All 35 routes are now
   derived from stable section labels; original node/source identifiers remain.
2. Two exported Lean theorem headers had stopped at a local "let B". Their
   complete types are restored in evidence/lean-correspondence-r21.json.
   The Lean declarations themselves were already complete and remain unchanged.
   Three further MAX5 profile facts cited in S2 are now included in the map.
3. "Formal lemmas" in the reading guide now reads "Numbered lemmas", avoiding
   confusion between manuscript numbering and kernel-checked declarations.
4. The introduction now explicitly states the same-field coefficient condition
   in its description of Brunck et al.'s Theorem 1.

CHECKED
- Both standalone TeX documents agree exactly with their authored components.
- 381 unique TeX labels and 592 cross-reference occurrences resolve.
- 75 numbered section labels agree with the compiled LaTeX auxiliary records.
- All 15 bibliography entries were checked against primary-source metadata and
  the cited claims/locators. No wrong-work citation was found. The precise
  Wang-Basu equations, Myrisiotis definition/network corollary and Ruess
  Proposition B.1 point to the intended statements. See reference-audit-r21.json.
- All 49 distinct printed file locators have an identified distribution/root.
- The 35 adopted nodes and 122 source records retain their statements, scopes,
  dependencies, identifiers and source hashes. The dependency graph is acyclic;
  the preliminary bounds remain independent of the final retained-29 cases.
- All 34 mapped Lean declarations match actual names, lines, full types and
  source hashes and belong to their corresponding closed root's import graph.
- All 10,143 MAX5 and 16,057 MAX6 project sources match accepted source records.
  The two completion reports and three copied MAX6 scope/root sources match
  their originals. No Lean execution or new source rebuild is claimed.
- All 410 relative links in README.md, research/RESULTS.md and
  research/FORMALIZATION.md resolve, including their dated historical entries.
- The two historical archives and both Lean distributions match their recorded
  sizes and SHA-256 pins. Every member of both historical archives was checked.
- All 59 statement/proof blocks and all 21 detailed case derivations are byte
  preserved. The approved abstract and nine critical scope guards are retained.
- Both PDFs compile in the editor and export successfully: 26 + 205 pages.
  Every page was rendered; 222 page rasters are identical to the preceding
  edition and all nine changed pages were inspected. Fonts are embedded, PDF
  destinations resolve, and there are no missing-glyph or overflow diagnostics.
- A fresh extraction reproduces the TeX sources byte for byte, passes the new
  consistency checker, release integrity checks and deliberate corruption
  controls. The upper identities, both network conversions and eight-edge
  geometry check also pass using only the extracted direct checkers.

SCOPE AND REMAINING EXTERNAL ITEM
The accepted formal theorem remains rational PM2 directional optimality on all
real inputs, in the fixed feature dictionary with a free feature-linear term.
The real-coefficient extension and fixed-PM2 arity ceiling have their separately
stated written arguments. The 18- and 51-neuron networks are construction bounds,
not unrestricted neuron-optimality results.

The reserved DOI is 10.5281/zenodo.24051030. Public accessibility of that record
and its executable artifact could not be confirmed by this audit. Both papers
already describe the deposit as pending; it is the author's separate task.
Historical snapshots and dated audit records are preserved as evidence. Earlier
status language in them is explicitly superseded by the accepted 31 October
checkpoint and is not a current claim of incompleteness.

REPRODUCE THE CURRENT DOCUMENT CHECKS
From an extracted paper-source.zip:
  python3 code/verify_release.py
  python3 code/check_consistency.py

For the additional accepted-source/import audit in the original project:
  python3 code/check_consistency.py --project-root /path/to/Max5-and-Max6

These commands distinguish navigation, file identity and recorded verification
from execution of Lean or a complete source rebuild.
